Stoke On Trent introduces citywide HMO Article 4
October 12, 2026

Stoke-on-Trent City Council has approved a citywide HMO Article 4 Direction, with 23 October 2026 announced as the start date. The change will remove the permitted development right that currently allows an ordinary house to become a small HMO without a planning application. The council will also hold a statutory consultation before deciding whether to confirm the direction. Stoke-on-Trent
For HMO investors, this changes the route from buying a property to bringing it into use. For tenants, it raises a wider concern about the supply of affordable rooms. At Foot Forward Property Investments, we understand why councils act when concentrations of HMOs cause problems, but we believe restrictions on new homes can make housing pressures worse when responsible developers face the same barriers as poor operators.
What does HMO Article 4 mean?
A small HMO normally falls within planning Use Class C4 and accommodates between three and six people from more than one household, sharing facilities such as a kitchen. An ordinary dwelling falls within Use Class C3. Where permitted development rights apply, a C3 house can generally change to C4 use without a planning application for that change of use.
An HMO Article 4 Direction removes that permission for the area it covers. Once Stoke-on-Trent’s direction takes effect, new C3-to-C4 conversions across the city will require planning permission. This is a planning control, not an automatic ban on HMOs. Larger HMOs accommodating more than six people already generally require planning permission, while HMO licensing remains a separate requirement. Stoke-on-Trent
What changes for investors?
An investor looking at a house in Stoke-on-Trent will need to assess whether the proposed HMO is likely to receive planning approval before committing to the development. A building might have enough space for good bedrooms, ensuite bathrooms and communal areas, but its suitability alone will not settle the planning decision. The council will also consider the proposal’s effect on the surrounding neighbourhood. Stoke-on-Trent
Planning applications introduce additional work, professional costs and uncertainty over the development timetable. Investors cannot assume that buying a house suitable for conversion means they can legally operate it as an HMO. An Article 4 Direction does not normally retrospectively remove an existing lawful HMO use, but buyers of existing properties still need evidence that the use is lawful. A licence and planning permission answer different questions. London Borough of Harrow
Poorly managed HMOs create problems for everyone
Pressure for Article 4 controls often builds where large concentrations of HMOs, poor management and repeated neighbourhood complaints occur together. Stoke-on-Trent’s council has specifically identified noise, waste and parking pressures as being most acute where HMO concentrations are highest. Its proposals also seek to preserve a balanced housing stock and improve accommodation standards. Stoke-on-Trent
We understand those concerns. When landlords fail to maintain properties, deal with rubbish, respond to neighbours or manage tenant behaviour, the effects extend beyond the front door. A street with several poorly run houses can become an unpleasant place to live, and residents understandably want action.
The frustration is that responsible operators then face additional barriers too. Developers providing spacious, compliant homes with proper management can find their proposals restricted because of the concentration of HMOs around them. Doing the job properly does not necessarily overcome a local policy limiting further conversions, even when the proposed home would offer a much higher standard.
Restricting supply can make housing pressures worse
Our concern is that citywide Article 4 restrictions can reduce the supply of new affordable rooms without resolving the management failures in existing properties. A planning requirement does not, by itself, repair a neglected house or make an absent landlord respond to complaints. Those problems need inspections, enforcement and accountable management.
If fewer shared homes become available while demand remains high, tenants have fewer choices and rents can face upward pressure. For someone who cannot afford a self-contained flat, a well-managed HMO may be the practical route to a secure home close to work. Restricting that option can increase housing insecurity and the risk of homelessness, particularly if replacement accommodation is not being delivered.
That is the housing trade-off councils need to address. Protecting neighbourhoods matters, but so does making room for responsible providers who can deliver affordable homes. We believe tackling poor operators directly should carry more weight than imposing barriers that also discourage good-quality development.
Why Foot Forward does it properly
At Foot Forward Property Investments, we have spent more than 34 years developing and managing HMOs for professional tenants. Our approach starts with choosing suitable properties in areas we can service properly, rather than squeezing as many rooms as possible into the cheapest building available.
We focus on five- and six-bedroom homes with ensuite bathrooms, comfortable communal areas and outdoor space. Our in-house team handles development and ongoing management, including maintenance, inspections and tenant issues. We only manage what we build, which keeps responsibility with the people who know the property and its construction.
We do not develop new HMOs in Article 4 areas. Our focus remains on suitable locations in South Yorkshire, where we assess local demand, existing supply and the practicality of managing each home before proceeding. Investors can explore our fully managed HMO investments, with development and day-to-day management handled by our own team.