What Q4 2025 data is telling us, and why South Yorkshire is often the smarter play
If you invest in HMOs in the North West, you have probably noticed a shift. Strong tenant demand still exists in many pockets, but the margin for error is smaller than it was a few years ago. More landlords are competing for the same tenant profiles, more stock is being delivered to similar specs, and in certain postcodes the “easy let” period has clearly cooled.
That is why Lendlord’s Q4 2025 HMO report is worth paying attention to. It confirms what many operators have been seeing on the ground, the North West is now carrying the weight of the UK’s biggest HMO concentration.
The headline, the North West now has the biggest share of HMOs
Lendlord’s Q4 2025 HMO analysis states that:
-
The North West now has the biggest share of HMOs in the country at 17.9% of the market, ahead of London.
-
This matters because when a region holds the largest share, the likelihood of saturation in popular hotspots rises.
The point is not that “more HMOs equals bad”. The point is that higher concentration often leads to:
-
More competition between landlords in the same postcodes
-
More properties being built to the same template
-
More pressure on occupancy for anything that is poorly laid out, poorly managed, or poorly presented
How saturation actually shows up, and why it is postcode-specific
Saturation rarely hits an entire region evenly. It tends to appear in clusters where investors have repeated the same strategy again and again, such as:
-
Around a single university or hospital corridor
-
Streets dominated by similar terrace conversions
-
Areas where agents have sold a standardised “HMO blueprint” repeatedly
In those pockets, tenants get more choice. When tenants have more choice, landlords must compete harder.
Competition is no longer just price, it is tenant experience and professional management
When supply rises, tenants become more selective. The HMOs that stay fully occupied in competitive markets tend to share three traits:
-
A layout that works in real life
Enough storage, sensible kitchen design, good flow through the home, and bathroom ratios that match the occupancy. -
A clear compliance position
Not just “it meets the rules”, it feels safe, maintained, and professionally run. -
Reliable management standards
Faster repairs, clearer communication, tighter house rules, and fewer ongoing issues.
This is exactly why “average” HMOs can start to struggle when competition increases, while well-designed, well-managed properties keep performing.
Why South Yorkshire is often a better bet for successful HMO investment
If the North West is becoming crowded in certain areas, it makes sense to look at markets where demand is strong but competition is more balanced. This is where South Yorkshire stands out.
South Yorkshire often offers:
-
Strong working-professional demand
-
Practical affordability compared to trophy-city pricing
-
Regeneration activity that improves long-term tenant appeal
-
Less of the “investor arms race” in many pockets compared to the most saturated HMO hotspots
Most importantly, we are not making a theoretical argument here.
We have over 34 years of property investment experience, developing and then managing HMO properties in South Yorkshire. If South Yorkshire was a saturated area where HMOs could not perform, we simply would not have survived for 34 years. Longevity in property, particularly in HMOs, only happens when the fundamentals support stable demand, resilient occupancy, and professional delivery.
Why the North East may face the same pattern next
The North East has attracted growing investor attention because it is often discussed as a higher-yielding region. The risk with high-yield headlines is that they can pull capital into the same hotspots quickly.
When that happens, you tend to see the same cycle the North West has experienced:
-
More investors targeting the same postcodes
-
More similar stock coming to market
-
More competition on pricing, incentives, and spec
-
Pressure on rent growth and occupancy for standard, undifferentiated HMOs
That does not mean the North East is “bad”. It means that as investor focus increases, saturation and competition become increasingly likely in the most popular pockets, unless supply and demand stay well balanced.
What to do if you still want to invest in the North West
You do not have to avoid the North West. You just need to be more deliberate:
-
Choose micro-locations, not “city-wide” assumptions
-
Avoid copying the most common local HMO format if the market is crowded
-
Underwrite using net yield, realistic voids, and realistic rent assumptions
-
Treat compliance and management quality as performance drivers, not afterthoughts
Prefer a market with less competition?
If you want to explore fully managed HMO opportunities in regions where saturation pressures are typically lower than the most competed hotspots, you can view current availability here:
www.footforwardproperties.co.uk/hmo-for-sale
