Cheap HMOs Are Cheap for a Reason

August 22, 2025

At Foot Forward, we speak to a lot of investors and review countless property deals. One thing we have noticed time and time again is that when a House in Multiple Occupation looks cheap, it is usually cheap for a reason. While the idea of snapping up a bargain property can be tempting, especially for those new to HMO investment, the reality is often far from a golden opportunity.

The Hidden Problems Behind Cheap HMOs

When an HMO is significantly underpriced compared to others in the market, it is usually because it comes with major issues. Many cheap HMOs we come across are in an absolute state, both in terms of condition and compliance. This means that the moment you take them on, you are inheriting a long list of expensive and time consuming problems.

Common issues include:

  • Rooms that cannot be legally let – We regularly see rooms that fall below the minimum legal size. These spaces cannot be used for tenants, which immediately impacts the potential rental income.

  • Lack of proper approvals – Some properties were never signed off by building control or simply cannot obtain the correct HMO licence to operate legally. This is a serious red flag that can leave an investor stuck with a property that cannot generate income.

  • Run down condition – Many cheap HMOs are poorly maintained and require huge amounts of work just to bring them up to standard. By the time you factor in the refurbishment costs, the financials often do not stack up.

Property Shells Becoming More Common

Another growing trend we are seeing is the increased number of property shells appearing on the market. These are homes where someone has attempted to convert the property into an HMO, only to realise later that either legally, space wise, or planning wise they cannot continue. What is left behind is often an incomplete and unattractive shell of a property, with ripped out interiors and no viable path forward.

For an investor, these shells may look like cheap opportunities, but in reality they are half finished projects that require significant investment to put right — and in many cases, the legal or planning barriers still make them unworkable.

Why Layout and Facilities Matter

Beyond legal compliance, the layout of many cheap HMOs is simply not fit for purpose. We see properties that are cramped, with awkward spaces that tenants do not want to live in. A lot of these HMOs are not fully ensuite, which is an increasingly important factor for modern tenants. Today’s renters expect convenience, privacy, and comfort, and shared outdated bathroom setups just do not meet the demand.

Parking and location also play a big role in tenant demand. Cheap HMOs are often located in areas with low capital appreciation and low rental demand, which means investors face limited tenant interest and very little chance of long term growth. When you combine poor demand with poor property condition, the result is usually a very low return on investment (ROI).

The Financials Rarely Add Up

Some investors may think they can turn a cheap HMO into a profitable one with a bit of work. The reality is that when you calculate the true costs of bringing the property up to standard — from compliance upgrades to full refurbishments — the numbers rarely make sense. What looks like a bargain at first glance quickly becomes a financial drain, especially in a location where rents and values are unlikely to rise.

Final Thoughts

At Foot Forward, our experience shows us that cheap HMOs are cheap for a reason. They are rarely hidden gems waiting to be developed, but more often problem properties that will consume time, money, and energy without delivering the expected returns.

If you are serious about investing in HMOs, it is always better to focus on quality properties that tick all the right boxes for compliance, layout, tenant demand, and long term profitability.


Frequently Asked Questions

Why are some HMOs so cheap?
Cheap HMOs usually come with hidden problems such as non compliant room sizes, missing approvals, or major refurbishment needs. In many cases, they cannot legally be rented out without significant investment.

What makes a good HMO investment?
A good HMO is fully licensed, compliant with minimum space standards, well maintained, and located in an area with strong rental demand. Properties with ensuite rooms and good layouts tend to attract better tenants and higher rents.

Can you turn a cheap HMO into a profitable one?
While it is possible in theory, the costs of making a substandard HMO compliant often outweigh the potential returns. The financials rarely stack up, which is why most cheap HMOs remain poor investments.

Are property shells a good opportunity?
Most shells are failed HMO projects that were stopped due to legal, planning, or compliance issues. They often require extensive work and may still be impossible to license, making them risky and unattractive to serious investors.